A Critique of Thank You for Smoking Essay - 1171 Words

A Critique of â€Å"Thank You for Smoking†¦.?† Peter Brimelow’s article â€Å"Thank You for Smoking†¦.?† is an essay that looks at a rather extreme perspective on smoking. Brimelow starts off by describing the many actions that are taken against the tobacco industry; he writes that in some states, the government is trying to make the tobacco industry pay certain health care costs. However, he then goes on to state that smoking may actually be good for one’s health. He uses various sources to show that smoking has positive effects on our bodies; he states the decrease in risk in numerous diseases. Brimelow uses medical journals to show that smoking decreases the risk of diseases like Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s. He also talks about some of†¦show more content†¦Brimelow follows up his major claim with a number of minor claims throughout the essay. A minor claim is a secondary claim, one where the arguer is trying to make a point to support his major claim (McFadden 40). Minor c laims are important because they strengthen your main point, or your major claim. His first minor claim is actually a rebuttal claim, which is â€Å"a claim that refutes the counterclaim† (McFadden 42). He compares smoking-related deaths per year to car-related deaths, saying they are similar. He states that both are a danger to a person’s health, but in many cases the reward outweighs the risk (Brimelow 141). He also compares the number between car-related and smoking-related deaths, but this hurts his claim because the number of smoking- related deaths is ten times greater than car-related deaths. So far Brimelow’s essay is a little weak because so far he has failed to give us enough information to support his argument. Then as a second minor claim, Brimelow goes on to discuss the advantages of smoking. He shows us that smoking decreases the risk in various diseases, such as Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s, prostate cancer and a few others. He also says that smoking lowers the rates of certain lung disorders andShow MoreRelatedRhetorical Analysis Of The Film Thank You For Smoking869 Words   |  4 PagesThank you for Smoking Introduction The film ‘Thank you for Smoking’ is a dark comedy where the primary protagonist, Nick Naylor is a lobbyist. He talks for the cigarette industry and will not extra the American Authorities or even the press. At the in advance, the film prominently tackles all these topics but deep down it also portrays the partnership between a dad and a son. Rhetorical and arguments analysis In a single conversation between a father and a son, Naylor coaches his son Joey by tellingRead MoreThe Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn By Mark Twain1840 Words   |  8 Pagesconfused and questions the society he lives in. As the novel progresses, so does Huckleberry’s moral development as he distinguishes between right and wrong, makes his own decisions, and understands the world around him. Through irony and his own critiques, Twain develops Huckleberry as a character who puts the interest of others before himself. Like people in today’s world, the environment and people in Huckleberry Finn’s life have made an impact on the kind of person he is in the novel. HuckleberryRead MoreEssay1543 Words   |  7 Pagesis embarrassing, not unlike when I got to know a pumpkin intimitately. Meh, about this time in 2002, I was wearing a pumpkin on my head sucking cheap vino from a straw, oh the high life of hearing your own vocals circumnavigating the lobes, whereby you feel as if your orange head may explode. If it was today, people would comment I was Donald Trump. Furthermore, a bulbous pumpkin is the most unsociable vegetable to have on your person - And to top it all off, yes the cream of pumpkin soup was an addedRead MoreSummary Of The Merry Family 1642 Words   |  7 PagesOrigin: New York Times The Disappearance of the Traditional Family Meal Imagine you just got off work and you arrive home to a hot meal waiting for you on the table. You walk in the door, take your coat off, and are greeted by a table full of smiling faces who have been patiently waiting for you to get home. That sounds like the ideal family supper, doesn’t it? Keeping that idea in mind, imagine the same scenario only you live in the 17th century, then imagine the scene again in the 19th century. WeRead MoreNever Let Me Go By Kazuo Ishiguro1989 Words   |  8 Pagesany chance to live a semblance of a normal live. Beyond merely describing the circumstances of three children who were cloned from others and raised strictly as organ donors, and are thus fated to die when their bodies give out, it is an ethical critique of a society which would allow science to operate in such a fashion. It does do in a subtle manner which nonetheless manages to capture the reader as they gradually become aware of the horrifying design behind the mysterious school in which the charactersRead MoreI Am Writing A Letter2806 Words   |  12 Pages I am writing you this letter in attempt to express every emotion that has been circumnavigating my mind for the last couple of weeks. My accretion of unhappiness, which I assume I am, or maybe it is the stress after all that has been assailing me. My anima tells me that I should wait until I see you in person, yet I feel like the longer I wait, the more my initial thoughts will become forgotten and all that I am left over with is a mood and uncertainty (this is my shy attempt to prevent that fromRead MoreEssay on Adopting a Healthy Lifestyle3423 Words   |  14 Pagesperson nourishes all their systems and all the functions of the body are intact, sickness is powerless (Gerson, 2012). The University of Berkeley, California (2008) writes that one of the biggest preventative measures in avoiding disease is to quit smoking, reduce your blood cholesterol, avoid hypertension, stay active, maintain a healthy weight, avoid diabetes, and balance alcohol consumption. In fewer words, eat healthy and stay active. Testing shows that vitamins A, C, E, B3 and B6 prevent the growthRead MoreInfluence of Hollywood films on the moral Values of Nigerian youths5511 Words   |  23 Pagessupport the hypothesis that visual image influence adolescent behavior. In another study, Sergeant, (2001) was of the opinion that a typical adolescent watching 150 film a year will be exposed to over 800 deceptions of overt immoral behaviors such as smoking and premarital sex. 2.4. MEDIA IMPERIALISM Media imperialism as a notional framework that has been subsumed under the broader umbrella of cultural imperialism. According to White (2001 p.98), scholars of different academic backgrounds and persuasionsRead MoreSummary Communication Theory13076 Words   |  53 Pagesorder to be a good objective theory of communication: First of all, the theory explains the data by describing why something happens and what the results are. It is able to predict future events and the explanation has to be relatively simply, e.g. if you have two version, take the easiest one. Furthermore, the hypothesis must be testable and disprovable if something is incorrect. Finally, the theory has to be useful and helps people to control their lives better as well as provides advice for difficultRead MoreSummary Communication Theory13084 Words   |  53 Pagesorder to be a good objective theory of communication: First of all, the theory explains the data by describing why something happens and what the resul ts are. It is able to predict future events and the explanation has to be relatively simply, e.g. if you have two version, take the easiest one. Furthermore, the hypothesis must be testable and disprovable if something is incorrect. Finally, the theory has to be useful and helps people to control their lives better as well as provides advice for difficult